A Guide to Authentic Hiring and Revealing Fake Candidates

January 03, 2024
A Guide to Authentic Hiring and Revealing Fake Candidates

Why settle for a bit of embellishment? While adding a touch of spice to a story may seem harmless, the stakes are significantly higher when job candidates choose to amplify their credentials and experiences. Unfortunately, a substantial number of candidates seem unfazed by the idea of adding false achievements throughout their job search.

This article will equip recruiters with a strategic toolkit to navigate through the rising tide of fake candidates and deceptive practices, emphasizing the importance of a proactive and multifaceted hiring approach.

Say Goodbye to Hiring Challenges

The Rise of Fake Candidates

According to a survey conducted in 2021 by the background check company Harver, a staggering 77.6% of respondents admitted to misrepresenting themselves to a moderate or greater extent during the hiring process. While some falsehoods may be relatively innocuous (with 34.50% falsely claiming to reside at an address other than their actual one), others can deprive your business of essential skills and expertise crucial for growth.

Without the tenacity and discernment of a seasoned HR, spotting these misrepresentations can be challenging, leaving you vulnerable to making a detrimental hire. The silver lining is that we’re not dealing with intricate schemes akin to those orchestrated by Danny Ocean. In reality, most misrepresentations are detectable – provided you have the time and awareness to do so. In our experience, the ability to identify fake candidates in recruitment hinges on possessing technical knowledge and applying specific techniques at each stage of the hiring process.

In today’s technologically advanced era, candidates are increasingly resorting to deceptive tactics to secure coveted positions. From concocting fake resumes and fabricating qualifications to engaging in identity theft and impersonation, the range of strategies employed is vast. A particularly concerning trend is the emergence of fake job interviews, where candidates go to great lengths to create a convincing but entirely false narrative.

Real-world examples underscore the severity of the issue. Instances of candidates with fabricated backgrounds infiltrating reputable companies highlight the critical need for strategies that transcend traditional screening methods.

Identifying Fake Candidates

1. Scrutinizing Resumes

The initial line of defense against deceptive candidates lies in a meticulous examination of their resumes. Beyond the standard scrutiny of work experience and qualifications, look for subtle inconsistencies that may indicate a lack of authenticity. Fake interview candidates often rely on impressive-sounding credentials that fall apart under close examination.

Cross-referencing information becomes paramount in this phase. Reach out directly to previous employers to verify employment history and achievements. Utilize professional networks to confirm qualifications and certifications, ensuring that the candidate’s claimed expertise aligns with reality.

2. Conducting Thorough Reference Checks

Reference checks serve as a powerful tool in uncovering deceptive candidates. Develop a comprehensive strategy for effective reference checks, going beyond the standard questions. Probing for specifics and red flags in responses can be instrumental in revealing deceptive intentions. A fake job interview may be preceded by a trail of references that don’t stand up to scrutiny.

Double Dippers and Serial Job Hoppers

1. Understanding the Motivations

Serial job hoppers and double dippers often have distinct motivations guiding their behavior. A desire for short-term gains may drive some, while others may lack a genuine commitment to the roles they pursue. Understanding these motivations is crucial for assessing a candidate’s long-term fit within the organization.

2. Red Flags in Employment History

Examine employment history closely, looking for patterns of frequent job changes without clear career progression. Pay attention to gaps in employment history and transitions that remain unexplained. Overlapping employment periods may indicate a candidate is engaged in double dipping, working for multiple employers simultaneously.

Utilizing Technology to Vet Candidates

1. Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) and Screening Tools

The advent of technology has given rise to advanced tools that can efficiently sift through resumes and identify patterns that may indicate deception. Applicant Tracking Systems (ATS) can be leveraged to streamline the initial stages of the hiring process, ensuring that fake candidates are filtered out early on.

2. Social Media and Online Presence

A candidate’s online presence can provide valuable insights into their authenticity. Scrutinize social media profiles for consistency with the information presented in their resume. A fake job interview may be preceded by a carefully curated online persona that doesn’t align with their professional background.

Behavioral Interviewing Techniques

1. Probing for Consistency

Behavioral interviewing is a powerful technique to unveil inconsistencies in a candidate’s narrative. Structure questions that prompt candidates to share specific examples of their experiences and pay attention to how they respond. Verbal and non-verbal cues during interviews can reveal discrepancies between the candidate’s words and actions.

2. Scenario-Based Questions

Integrate scenario-based questions into interviews to assess problem-solving skills and authenticity. Candidates genuinely suited for a role will provide thoughtful and consistent responses, while those with deceptive intentions may struggle to maintain their façade.

Building a Comprehensive Hiring Strategy

1. Collaborating with Background Check Services

To add an extra layer of verification, collaborate with reputable third-party background check services. These services can conduct in-depth investigations, providing insights beyond what may be accessible through standard channels. This step is particularly crucial when dealing with candidates for sensitive or high-level positions.

2. Continuous Improvement

Hiring processes should not be static but rather dynamic and adaptable. Learn from past experiences and continually update and refine hiring strategies to stay ahead of evolving deceptive tactics. Encourage ongoing education and awareness among recruiters, fostering a culture of vigilance and adaptability in the face of the ever-changing challenges of the hiring landscape.

3. Emphasizing the Human Element

In the pursuit of a comprehensive hiring strategy, it’s essential not to overlook the human element. Encourage open communication and transparency during the interview process, creating an environment where candidates feel comfortable being themselves. A genuine candidate is more likely to thrive in an authentic organizational culture.


To find the right talent, recruiters must navigate a landscape rife with deceptive tactics employed by fake candidates, double dippers, and other ill-suited applicants. By incorporating a multi-faceted approach that includes meticulous resume scrutiny, effective reference checks, technological tools, and behavioral interviewing techniques, organizations can build a robust defense against deceptive applicants. Continuous improvement and a proactive stance in the face of evolving challenges will ensure a hiring process that not only identifies and filters out fake candidates but also sets the foundation for a successful and resilient workforce.

Read more: Top 10 Biggest Hiring Challenges Recruiters Face in 2024

Hire Xperti



Candidate signup

Create a free profile and find your next great opportunity.


Employer signup

Sign up and find a perfect match for your team.


How it works

Xperti vets skilled professionals with its unique talent-matching process.


Join our community

Connect and engage with technology enthusiasts.